Delhi Wallas do not think the Raj Thackeray's way but...
By Sandeep Datta
Presence of people of different tastes, cultures and backgrounds is an advantage for the development of any place. Dilli, named Delhi by Britishers, is one such example of it. The confluence of people of all religions, castes and creeds has offered it a unique recognition of being a cosmopolitan city.
For having almost all amenities to offer a luxurious life and employment, Dilli has turned a major fascination for people across the country to settle here.
But there are some disturbing habits and issues that irk people born and brought up in Dilli about these visitors, migrants or the new settlers.
Day in or day out, a lot of non-natives of Dilli speak so much ill about this place. Be it rains, summer, strikes, lifestyle or a rising cost of living or difficulty to own a house or media reports about the city, all seem to serve as fodder for the city's criticism. The prevailing situation could be fare worse in different places but Dilli is viewed to the 'worst' among all.
It shocks to hear people arriving from far off regions of the country at this place -- Dilli -- known for having a big heart to accept all, criticising it as if this is worst place to live.
Like any other place of the world, Dilli also has its dark side which may not be liked by a lot of people. But like one's own house, no matter how many things maybe making us uncomfortable being in it, we never like our home being criticised at least by people who visit it for their motives.
I appreciate the local residents who despite noticing such visiting or non-native visitors routinely do not react bluntly ever lest it should also be equated with Australia or Britain, today known for racist violence.
But, at times, it compels as a native of Dilli, to point out what is largely being ignored by the Mast or, carefree Dilliwallas -- the visitors' attitude. It feels unbearable to watch Dilli and its residents being lampooned for everything. And, these critics being those who arrive uninvited after turning helpless in their native places to earn a livelihood or study!
Prominent objectionable habits among most of these (not all) visitors from different parts of the country is their basic view about the natives of Delhi and everything that the place is today known for in the world.
The general impresssion of Dilli made on the basis of observing something or anything in one part of the city may be completely fallicious, as be it the east, west, south or north Delhi and related parts are completely different in almost everything. The approach of people, their habits, their lifestyle, their awareness level, street smartness or lifestyle can surprise anyone. This is because residents's lifestyle or habits in any area of Delhi are influenced by distinct things or living or economic conditions.
But the topmost thing that I find outrageous among some of the visiting youngsters from the northeast or West Bengal is their dislike for Hindi, the Rashtra Bhasha or national language.
It galvanizes a person like me, who has always liked people beyond their region or language, to see the disgust such people have for everything in the north India or Delhi, in particular, or for Punjabis, more specifically.
The proverb ‘Jist Thali mein Roti khai usi Thali Mein Ched kiya’ or making holes in the same saucer one is given to eat comes to my mind everytime I come across such people who hate the very place; Delhi which has given them shelter or an opportunity to earn a decent livelihood or study.
It shocks oneself to notice how much ungrateful some of these people are.
They enjoy critcising everybody and everything they see in Dilli, ignoring the fact that how, contrary to rest of the India, people of this place has literally shared their saucer with them without ever complaining. Natives of Dilli have no separate reservation in jobs or any opportunity, a fact contrary to rest of the Indian states that have such provision to safeguard their first right on anything in their native State.
Be it education, employment in any walk of life, ration on control-rate shops, space to live or celebrate, people of Delhi have shared everything with them without hesitation. But still, such a rudeness, such ungratefulness, such unobliged attitude? It shocks anyone here literally.
God forbid, if people of Delhi actually started taking such people’s hatred for local people here by heart and asserted their first right to this place, what might happen then?
The growing frustration could compel them to make them force all migrants or visitors from other States to run away. What if some of the natives of Delhi started beating them with Chappals (slippers) or sticks or, if gently, then by social boycott; by not employing, not renting them, not giving them space to utilize any possible opportunity to live comfortably here?
People of Delhi have so far been tolerant and accommodating all these years, but God forbid if they turned intolerant. The time seems fast approaching when anyone criticizing Delhi or its dominant population of Punjabis may face angst in the form of public thrashing and nobody may dare to intervene.
I won't find it objectionable if somone invited such an extreme reaction (read public thrashing) for bad-mouthing about the very place and people that have given them a reason to live here and be happy with their peculiar lifestyle.
The question is -- Why cannot we learn to respect and value the place we visit or people we get a chance to live with? Why cannot we facilitate change instead of criticising things or people of a place? If Dilli belongs to everyone in the country, its lacunaes or imperfections are also everyone's responsibility. Before critising Dilli, we must ask to ourselves what have we done to make it a better place?
Or, if we really find it such a bad place, why don't we leave it as it is and better look for some other place to be. Thank God, Dillwalas hate to think the Raj Thackeray's way.
(Writer's Note: While writing this write up I have kept three words--Refugees, Migrants, and the Guests--in my mind to evaluate or comment any situation being faced by people of Dilli (the natives or people who were born and brought up in Dilli) by people in Dilli (the non-natives of Dilli).
This latest piece is an attempt to reach an answer that while visiting a place what basic courtesy one should maintain?, especially if that place is going to offer livelihood for one's family and oneself.
Having written the write up about some of my irritating countrymen from different parts of the country or country, I would still say I am indebted to my friends from Bihar, Kerala, Karnataka, and the north east States mainly whose association shaped my personality and influenced me a lot. And, I don't wish to criticise their native places despite knowing a lot of negative about it.
I still have lot of things to appreciate about them, as I hold deep affection for all of them.)
By Sandeep Datta
Presence of people of different tastes, cultures and backgrounds is an advantage for the development of any place. Dilli, named Delhi by Britishers, is one such example of it. The confluence of people of all religions, castes and creeds has offered it a unique recognition of being a cosmopolitan city.
For having almost all amenities to offer a luxurious life and employment, Dilli has turned a major fascination for people across the country to settle here.
But there are some disturbing habits and issues that irk people born and brought up in Dilli about these visitors, migrants or the new settlers.
Day in or day out, a lot of non-natives of Dilli speak so much ill about this place. Be it rains, summer, strikes, lifestyle or a rising cost of living or difficulty to own a house or media reports about the city, all seem to serve as fodder for the city's criticism. The prevailing situation could be fare worse in different places but Dilli is viewed to the 'worst' among all.
It shocks to hear people arriving from far off regions of the country at this place -- Dilli -- known for having a big heart to accept all, criticising it as if this is worst place to live.
Like any other place of the world, Dilli also has its dark side which may not be liked by a lot of people. But like one's own house, no matter how many things maybe making us uncomfortable being in it, we never like our home being criticised at least by people who visit it for their motives.
I appreciate the local residents who despite noticing such visiting or non-native visitors routinely do not react bluntly ever lest it should also be equated with Australia or Britain, today known for racist violence.
But, at times, it compels as a native of Dilli, to point out what is largely being ignored by the Mast or, carefree Dilliwallas -- the visitors' attitude. It feels unbearable to watch Dilli and its residents being lampooned for everything. And, these critics being those who arrive uninvited after turning helpless in their native places to earn a livelihood or study!
Prominent objectionable habits among most of these (not all) visitors from different parts of the country is their basic view about the natives of Delhi and everything that the place is today known for in the world.
The general impresssion of Dilli made on the basis of observing something or anything in one part of the city may be completely fallicious, as be it the east, west, south or north Delhi and related parts are completely different in almost everything. The approach of people, their habits, their lifestyle, their awareness level, street smartness or lifestyle can surprise anyone. This is because residents's lifestyle or habits in any area of Delhi are influenced by distinct things or living or economic conditions.
But the topmost thing that I find outrageous among some of the visiting youngsters from the northeast or West Bengal is their dislike for Hindi, the Rashtra Bhasha or national language.
It galvanizes a person like me, who has always liked people beyond their region or language, to see the disgust such people have for everything in the north India or Delhi, in particular, or for Punjabis, more specifically.
The proverb ‘Jist Thali mein Roti khai usi Thali Mein Ched kiya’ or making holes in the same saucer one is given to eat comes to my mind everytime I come across such people who hate the very place; Delhi which has given them shelter or an opportunity to earn a decent livelihood or study.
It shocks oneself to notice how much ungrateful some of these people are.
They enjoy critcising everybody and everything they see in Dilli, ignoring the fact that how, contrary to rest of the India, people of this place has literally shared their saucer with them without ever complaining. Natives of Dilli have no separate reservation in jobs or any opportunity, a fact contrary to rest of the Indian states that have such provision to safeguard their first right on anything in their native State.
Be it education, employment in any walk of life, ration on control-rate shops, space to live or celebrate, people of Delhi have shared everything with them without hesitation. But still, such a rudeness, such ungratefulness, such unobliged attitude? It shocks anyone here literally.
God forbid, if people of Delhi actually started taking such people’s hatred for local people here by heart and asserted their first right to this place, what might happen then?
The growing frustration could compel them to make them force all migrants or visitors from other States to run away. What if some of the natives of Delhi started beating them with Chappals (slippers) or sticks or, if gently, then by social boycott; by not employing, not renting them, not giving them space to utilize any possible opportunity to live comfortably here?
People of Delhi have so far been tolerant and accommodating all these years, but God forbid if they turned intolerant. The time seems fast approaching when anyone criticizing Delhi or its dominant population of Punjabis may face angst in the form of public thrashing and nobody may dare to intervene.
I won't find it objectionable if somone invited such an extreme reaction (read public thrashing) for bad-mouthing about the very place and people that have given them a reason to live here and be happy with their peculiar lifestyle.
The question is -- Why cannot we learn to respect and value the place we visit or people we get a chance to live with? Why cannot we facilitate change instead of criticising things or people of a place? If Dilli belongs to everyone in the country, its lacunaes or imperfections are also everyone's responsibility. Before critising Dilli, we must ask to ourselves what have we done to make it a better place?
Or, if we really find it such a bad place, why don't we leave it as it is and better look for some other place to be. Thank God, Dillwalas hate to think the Raj Thackeray's way.
(Writer's Note: While writing this write up I have kept three words--Refugees, Migrants, and the Guests--in my mind to evaluate or comment any situation being faced by people of Dilli (the natives or people who were born and brought up in Dilli) by people in Dilli (the non-natives of Dilli).
This latest piece is an attempt to reach an answer that while visiting a place what basic courtesy one should maintain?, especially if that place is going to offer livelihood for one's family and oneself.
Having written the write up about some of my irritating countrymen from different parts of the country or country, I would still say I am indebted to my friends from Bihar, Kerala, Karnataka, and the north east States mainly whose association shaped my personality and influenced me a lot. And, I don't wish to criticise their native places despite knowing a lot of negative about it.
I still have lot of things to appreciate about them, as I hold deep affection for all of them.)